Wood vs. Vinyl Windows: What to Choose for Your Replacement Project in 2023?

Windows are essential to any home, and choosing the suitable material for your window replacement project might be daunting. Two of the most popular options in the market today are wood and vinyl windows.

Both materials have their advantages and disadvantages, making it difficult to determine which one is the right choice for your home improvement. 
In this article, experts from Ecoline Windows will help us weigh all the pros and cons of wood and vinyl windows to help homeowners make informed decisions.

Wood or Vinyl for New Windows? Ultimate Comparison.
​
Wood Windows:
●    Wood windows have a classic and timeless look unmatched by other materials. 
●    They are also natural insulators, making them an excellent energy-efficient choice. 
●    Another advantage of wood windows is that they are easy to paint or stain to match any home exterior.
However, wood windows are more expensive than vinyl models and require more maintenance. They can rot or warp if not properly sealed, resulting in costly repairs. Also, wood windows need to be painted or stained every few years to keep them looking good.
​
Vinyl Windows:
●  Vinyl windows are a more affordable option than wood windows. 
● They require little-to-no maintenance and are resistant to fading, warping, and rotting. 
●  They are also great insulators and come in various colours and styles.
● Vinyl windows are easy to customize, allowing for more configurations and feature inclusion
However, vinyl windows are less durable than wood and can crack or warp in extreme temperatures. 

​Breaking down the costs
When it comes to cost, wood windows are generally more expensive than vinyl windows. However, they can be a better investment in the long run as they are more durable and require less maintenance. 
On the other hand, vinyl windows are more budget-friendly, but they may not last as long as wood windows if not properly maintained.
●      On average, a medium-sized vinyl window can cost $400-$700, based on style, glass type, hardware, etc.
●       Wood windows come with a minimum price of $600 per unit
All in all, vinyl units are considered the best windows in Alberta in terms of quality/price ratio.

Maintenance
Wood windows require more maintenance than vinyl units. They need to be painted or stained every few years to keep them looking good, and they can rot or warp if not properly sealed. Regular caulking and weatherstripping are also necessary to keep them airtight and energy efficient.
Vinyl windows, on the other hand, are low maintenance and require very little upkeep. They are resistant to fading, warping, and rotting and can be easily cleaned with just a simple wipe-down. They are also designed to be stable and weather-resistant, making them popular among the majority of homeowners.

Insulation and Energy Efficiency:
Both wood and vinyl windows are good insulators and can help keep your home energy-efficient. 
●      Wood windows are a natural insulator, while vinyl windows have a unique thermal design that helps keep your home warm in cold seasons and cool in hot ones. 
●      Both types of windows can be equipped with a special LoE coating, which reflects heat back into the room during the winter and keeps the heat out during the summer. This can aid in decreasing your energy expenses and enhance the comfort level inside your home throughout the year.
According to the statistics, windows account for up to 25% of a home's energy bill. Both wood and vinyl windows can help improve energy efficiency in homes, but there are some differences in their performance.
​
Wood windows have a natural insulating property, with an R-value (a measure of thermal resistance) of around 0.8 per inch. 
When equipped with Low-E coatings, wood windows can further enhance energy efficiency by reflecting heat back into the room during the winter and keeping the heat out during the summer. This can result in potential energy savings of up to 30%.
​
Vinyl windows have a unique thermal design that helps keep homes warm in winter and cool in summer. Their R-value ranges from 3.0 to 3.7 per inch, significantly higher than wood windows. When equipped with Low-E coatings, vinyl windows can reduce energy consumption by up to 40%, resulting in significant energy savings for homeowners.

​Customization:
Both wood and vinyl window models come with a range of customization options.
●       Wood windows can be easily painted or stained to match any home exterior, but the colour selection may be limited to traditional home designs. 
●       Vinyl windows,  offer a wider range of colours and styles and can be ordered in any shade. 
Homeowners are also welcome to customize new windows with hardware, glazing, and sizes to align with personal preferences and the home exterior..

Wood vs Vinyl Windows – Which  Architectural Home Styles Do They Fit In?
​
Wood and vinyl windows can work well with a variety of architectural styles, but there are some styles where each material may be better suited.
●       For traditional and historic homes, wood windows are often the preferred choice as they have a classic and timeless look that matches the aesthetic of these homes. For example, wood windows can complement the look of Colonial, Victorian, or Craftsman-style homes. Wood windows are also ideal for homes with natural wood features, such as exposed timber beams or wood siding.

●    Vinyl windows, are versatile and can work well with many modern or contemporary home styles. They are often used in homes with a minimalist or sleek design aesthetic, such as Mid-Century Modern or Contemporary-style homes. Vinyl windows are also popular in homes with a more transitional style, blending traditional and modern design elements.
​
Final Say
When it comes to choosing between wood and vinyl windows, it ultimately depends on your budget, the style of your home, and your personal preferences. Wood windows are an excellent choice for homeowners willing to spend a bit more money and put in a bit more work. They have a timeless look, are natural, and can be easily painted or stained to match any home exterior. They are also an eco-friendlier option as they are a natural resource.
Vinyl windows are more budget-friendly and trendy among North American homeowners due to easy maintenance, different hardware and customization options.

I hope this article helps explain what you need to know when selecting replacement windows for your new home.